Question: In your July newsletter you quoted a letter about a radio Bible teacher who, though a Christian, remains in the Catholic Church in order to win others to Christ. You seemed to approve of her remaining in the RCC. Do you? | thebereancall.org

TBC Staff

Question: In your July newsletter you quoted a letter about a radio Bible teacher who, though a Christian, remains in the Catholic Church in order to win others to Christ. You seemed to approve of her remaining in the RCC. Do you?

Response: That was a separate issue which I didn’t deal with, inasmuch as I don’t know the person or the circumstances. Now that you’ve asked, however, your question is answered in Scripture where we have the perfect example from Jesus (and from the apostles who followed Him). Jesus attended the synagogue and even participated (Lk 4:16), though Judaism was apostate. So did the apostles in order to confront unbelieving Jews. They were allowed to preach there for a time but, like Jesus (Lk 4:17-30, etc.), the apostles were eventually thrown out (Acts:17:2-14, etc.).

That a person can remain in good standing as a Catholic for any length of time after becoming a true Christian raises serious questions as to (1) that person’s willingness to present the gospel clearly and (2) his or her participation in Roman Catholic sacraments. The gospel can only be presented meaningfully if it is contrasted with the errors the hearers believe. (See “Quotable”) No one could remain long in the good graces of Catholic friends, to say nothing of the Catholic clergy, if one confronted the real issues. Nor could a true Christian participate at all in Catholic sacraments (the Mass, for example) which deny the gospel and claim to be the means of passing out grace and salvation in installments.